Mr. President, Some Bicycles Please…
I am on the road again for work, in Europe this time. Fortunately, my Democracy Center colleagues back in Bolivia have agreed to help me keep good Blog postings coming while I travel. This one is from Jeanette Bailey, a Fulbright scholar from the US who is working with us this year. Jeanette is living in Bolivia's altiplano, studying how globalization is affecting what Bolivians have on their plate -- quite literally -- to see how global economics affect what Bolivians have to eat and don't.
Here's a reflection from Jeanette, from the altiplano. I hope you find it interesting.
Jim
Mr. President, Some Bicycles Please…
It is the end of a long day of training for community health volunteers in a rural village some 8 hours drive outside of La Paz. We are celebrating with a large dinner of vegetable soup, rice, chicken, onions, tomatoes and Bolivian staple, potatoes. No dinner is complete in Bolivia without potatoes. At the end of the meal one of the community health volunteers stands up and announces he’d like to make a proposal to the blonde gringa standing in the corner of the room. The room falls immediately silent, and I find myself in an awkward spotlight.
“I’d like to ask the U.S. citizen in the room, Yaneth (as they pronounce my name, Jeanette) to speak to her president about getting us some bicycles.” I know exactly what he is referring to. Some of these community health volunteers have walked 4 or more hours to arrive at this workshop, leaving families, aging parents, children and the stress of the harvest season behind to come and learn about preventing malnutrition, diarrhea and other common childhood illnesses. They will return to their home communities and conduct visits to their neighbors’ homes, with the intent of imparting newfound knowledge on health, hygiene and nutrition. They are the grassroots leaders in their villages; the mothers and fathers who are determined to raise the next generation “sano, fuerte y inteligente.”
This plea for bicycles reflects one of many challenges faced by rural Bolivian citizens who wish to develop their own communities. Eight hours walking per day is not conducive to even the most motivated of budding community leader to attend a capacitation workshop. They are motivated, they are concerned, and they desperately want to improve their communities. But even with all this, sometimes the fight against poverty comes down to the simple things. Like too much rain making the rivers impassable or the mountain paths too difficult, or the inability to find a caretaker for the kids because it’s harvest season and the grandparents and neighbors are in the fields. Just arriving to capacitation training is hard enough.
The solutions are sometimes equally simple. Wouldn’t a bike make it a bit easier? Shorten that 4-hour one-way trip down to one, maybe? And if you need a bike, whom do you ask? Who better than an American citizen, someone with a direct link to the developed, powerful, wealthy nation that seems to have entered the consciousness of every small, underdeveloped, poor village worldwide?
I answer his question with a joke in kind, though I’m not so sure his question was a joke. Though the room laughs, there is a brutal truth underlying the quick back and forth banter.
“Of course, I’ll send him a letter directly; in fact I’ll call him this evening.” More laughter, but not without expectation. Perhaps I shouldn’t have responded with a joke. Perhaps it would’ve been better to be honest.
Why turn to the U.S. to solve the problems of this community? Why reinforce the evident feeling of dependency on U.S. handouts?
But no, we never think of these things until it is too late. I thought perhaps that post-dinner dialogue would be the end of it, but the next day, 3 or 4 volunteers came to me and asked if I really thought it would be possible to get those bikes from Mr. Bush.
Sometimes fighting poverty comes down to the complicated things, too. Like U.S. policy and power and the inherent mentality of development dependency. How do we truly capacitate a community leader to develop her or his own community, disengaging capacitation from dependency?
The fight against poverty is a winding road, or rather, in the Bolivian Andes, a steep, muddy mountain pass. It will take caution, focus, determination and integrity. For any of us who want to join the fight for development, we will have to pay attention to every step and constantly ask ourselves: Are we helping, or hurting? Are we capacitating, or unwittingly participating in a new form of colonization?
by Jeanette Bailey

The Democracy Center, based in Cochabamba Bolivia and San Francisco California, works globally to advance human rights through a combination of investigation and reporting, training citizens in the art of public advocacy, and organizing international citizen campaigns. If you like the Blog, consider becoming a subscriber to The Democracy Center's free e-newsletter by sending us an email at 